The Martini Police combine gritty indie-rock guitars and an infectious rhythm with a story of lost love, unanswered messages and the difficulty of moving on. “What We Were” finds emotional weight in the smallest details.

There’s something about a really good indie-rock track that can make even the most difficult subject matter sound irresistible. The Martini Police understand that balance on “What We Were”, a guitar-driven single that takes the familiar territory of lost love and gives it a welcome injection of energy, attitude and emotion.

From the opening guitar work, there’s an immediate sense of purpose. The track wastes little time getting into its stride, with punchy drums, a solid bassline and layers of electric guitars creating a sound that feels both urgent and infectious. This isn’t a band interested in wrapping heartbreak in a pretty little bow. Instead, they give it a driving rhythm and let the emotions do the talking.

What makes the track interesting is the contrast between its musical confidence and the vulnerability running through the lyrics. The vocal delivery has a conversational edge during the verses, almost as though we’re listening to someone trying to make sense of a relationship that refuses to stay in the past. There’s frustration here, but also a sense of desperation that gradually becomes harder to ignore as the song opens up.

The songwriting is at its strongest when it concentrates on the little things. An old photograph, a name unexpectedly overheard, letters that remain tucked away and messages that will never receive a reply. These are everyday details, but they’re precisely the things that can catch you off guard when you thought you’d moved on. The Martini Police capture that experience without making the subject feel overly sentimental.

The chorus brings a welcome change in scale. The guitars become bigger and more atmospheric, the vocals take on greater intensity, and that repeated plea to save what’s left of the relationship gives the track its emotional centre. There’s a particularly effective image of trying to stop the rain with bare hands, which captures the futility of fighting to keep something together when it’s already slipping away.

I also like the use of the answering-machine refrain. It’s a small detail, but it adds another layer to the story. One person is still trying to make contact, still looking for a response, while the other seems to have moved on. It’s a familiar situation, but one that carries considerable emotional weight.

As the track progresses, the reality of that separation becomes increasingly difficult to escape. News that an ex-partner has found a new job and started a different life is painful enough, but the image of seeing her board a train holding somebody else’s hand brings the story into particularly sharp focus. It’s a moment that feels almost cinematic, and one that many listeners will recognise for all the wrong reasons.

Musically, the band do a good job of keeping everything moving. The rhythm section provides a strong backbone, while the guitars give the song its character without overwhelming the vocal. There are a couple of lyrical moments that don’t quite land as naturally as the stronger imagery elsewhere, but they do little to undermine the overall impact.

What I particularly appreciate about “What We Were” is that it doesn’t try to manufacture a happy ending. Some relationships don’t bring the closure we want, and sometimes the hardest part isn’t accepting that somebody has gone, but accepting that the future you imagined together is no longer yours to share.

The Martini Police have taken a subject that’s been explored countless times in music and given it their own energetic indie-rock treatment. It’s an engaging combination of gritty guitars, an infectious driving rhythm and a vocal performance that carries genuine feeling.

“What We Were” looks back at a relationship that has run its course, but there’s plenty of life in the music itself. It’s an engaging piece of indie rock that balances emotional vulnerability with an energetic sound, making it well worth a listen.

*

Love what we do? Rock the Joint Magazine is completely free — no paywalls, no ads ruining the vibe — just passionate music journalism for 1,000+ readers a day. If you enjoy hanging out with us, please consider hitting the “Support Us” button and buying us a coffee on Ko-Fi. Even a small donation genuinely helps keep the magazine running, lets us publish more features, and reminds us that people value independent music writing.

Stream music from The Martini Police here

Review by Leon Roberts

Freelance Music Journalist

Join Rock the Joint Magazine on the road to the best independent music journalism, interviews, and reviews. We cover Rock, Country, Jazz, Blues and Christian music. Support us on Ko-Fi (link on each page) to help the magazine grow and value independent journalism.